Every Thanksgiving table has someone nursing a glass of tap water for four hours. Maybe they’re driving. Maybe they stopped drinking a while back and the family still hasn’t figured out what to hand them. Maybe they’re nine. Whoever it is, they deserve better, and so does everyone else, because non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks are one of the easiest wins of the whole day.
The turkey gets a brine and a printed schedule taped to the fridge. The pie gets a practice run the weekend before. The drinks get whatever’s left in the garage fridge.
It doesn’t take much to fix that. A few bottles of good soda, the cranberry juice you already bought, a couple of herbs. Below you’ll find six drinks, a cheat sheet for matching soda to the menu, and a way to set it all up so you’re not stuck playing bartender between the gravy and the rolls.
Why more tables are skipping the wine this year
For a long time, the non-drinker at Thanksgiving was the exception. Not anymore. This year Gallup found that only 54% of American adults drink at all, tied with last year for the lowest number since it started asking in 1939.
Do the math on a table of twelve. Five or six of the people passing the stuffing might pass on the wine, too. They aren’t asking for a special menu. They just want something in their glass that looks like somebody thought about it.
Thanksgiving food also happens to make the best possible case for bubbles. It’s gravy, butter, and marshmallows melted on top of sweet potatoes, which is wonderful and also a lot. Something cold, fizzy, and a little sharp resets your mouth between bites. Wine does that. So does a good ginger beer. That’s really the whole argument for building your non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks around craft soda.
If you’ve thrown a dry party before, most of what you learned still applies. We covered the basics in our guide to hosting a party without alcohol. Thanksgiving just has more gravy.
6 non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks you can make with craft soda
None of these needs a shaker or a trip to a specialty store. Two or three ingredients, a glass of ice, done. Each recipe makes one drink, and the only real rule is to pour the soda last so it doesn’t go flat while you’re hunting for the lime.
1. Cranberry Ginger Fizz. Two ounces of unsweetened cranberry juice, a squeeze of lime, and 4 ounces of Ginger Beer over ice. Clap a sprig of rosemary between your palms before you drop it in. It feels silly, and it makes the glass smell like a Christmas tree lot. This is the one people will ask about.
2. Cider Root Beer Spritz. Three ounces of cold apple cider topped with 4 ounces of Root Beer, stirred with a cinnamon stick you leave in the glass. It sounds like an odd couple until you taste it. The cider makes the root beer brighter, like it took a walk through an orchard.
3. Black Cherry Pomegranate Sparkler. An ounce of pomegranate juice in a wine glass, 4 ounces of Black Cherry on top, and a spoonful of seeds. It’s dark red and a little tart, and in a stemmed glass it passes for something you’d order at a nice restaurant.
4. Orange Cream Sunrise. Half Orange, half Cream, a twist of orange peel. Yes, it’s a creamsicle. Nobody at the table is going to complain.
5. Pumpkin Pie Cream Float. A scoop of vanilla ice cream, a pinch of pumpkin pie spice, and Cream soda poured slowly down the side of the glass so it doesn’t foam over. (It will foam over a little anyway.) If you made our Halloween soda floats, think of this as the November sequel.
6. Peach Sweet Tea Spritz. Three ounces of cold black tea, 4 ounces of Peach, a lemon wheel. Light, not too sweet, and exactly right around 2 p.m., when the turkey is resting and everyone is pretending they aren’t starving.
A note on cold: Put the bottles in the fridge the night before and stick your glasses in the freezer for 15 minutes before people arrive. Cold soda holds its bubbles longer, so your Thanksgiving mocktails will still have some fizz left by the time the pie comes out.
What to pour with what: craft soda and the Thanksgiving menu
Nobody needs a sommelier for soda. Still, a little matching goes a long way, and it’s the easiest way to make non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks feel like part of the meal instead of something set out on the side. Here’s where I’d start:
- Turkey and stuffing get Ginger Beer. The spice cuts right through the gravy.
- Ham gets Black Cherry. Salt and dark fruit have been friends for a long time.
- Sweet potato casserole gets Orange, because that much brown sugar needs some citrus.
- Mashed potatoes and green bean casserole can handle Root Beer, which is earthier than people expect.
- Pumpkin pie gets Cream. Vanilla and warm spice were always going to end up together. (Ever wonder why cream soda tastes like that? Here’s what cream soda actually is.)
- Pecan or apple pie gets Root Beer again, ideally with a scoop of ice cream in it.
Then put two or three flavors on the table and let people figure it out. Someone always ends up loudly announcing that black cherry and ham is a revelation. That’s half the fun.
Friendsgiving drinks for a crowd (or how to stop being the bartender)
Friendsgiving runs on a different clock. People drift in between noon and four, somebody shows up with a dish nobody assigned, and whoever’s hosting spends most of the day with their head in the oven. The last thing you need is to be mixing drinks one at a time.
So don’t. Set up a station and walk away.
Pick two drinks, tops. The Cranberry Ginger Fizz and the Cider Root Beer Spritz both scale easily. Mix the juice and cider bases in pitchers ahead of time, but leave the soda in the bottles so it stays sharp.
Fill a galvanized tub or a clean cooler with ice and bury the bottles in it. Set out small bowls of rosemary, cinnamon sticks, orange peel, lime wedges, and pomegranate seeds. A handwritten card with two lines per drink is plenty. People love following instructions when the stakes are this low.
How much do you need? Figure two or three bottles per person over a long afternoon. Some people will mix, some will drink straight from the bottle, and the kids will be back for seconds before you’ve even sat down.
A setup like this also quietly makes non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks the default. They’re right there on the counter, not hiding in the back of the fridge behind the cranberry sauce. Good Friendsgiving drinks should be the first thing people see, not something they have to ask for. If you want more ideas to carry you through winter, our list of soda mocktails you can make at home is a good place to keep going.
Non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks for the kids’ table and everyone else
The kids’ table is always having more fun than the grown-up table. Everybody knows it. Lean into it.
Pour small floats with Glazed Donut or Strawberry and a spoonful of vanilla ice cream. Hand out plastic wine glasses, because a nine-year-old with Grape soda in a stemmed glass sits up straighter than you’ve ever seen. Let the youngest person at the table lead the toast. It’ll be short, possibly incoherent, and the best part of the meal.
The adults who aren’t drinking deserve the same treatment, minus the plastic. Put their drink in the same glass as the wine and garnish it the same way. It’s a small thing. It’s also the difference between feeling included and feeling like you got handed the kids’ menu. When non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks look as good as everything else on the table, nobody has to explain themselves.
If someone’s watching sugar, Diet Root Beer, Diet Cream, and Diet Black Cherry swap straight into any of the recipes above. And if you tried our non-alcoholic 4th of July drinks this summer, you already know the drill. Same idea, more sweaters.
Why Polly’s Pop fits the Thanksgiving table
Thanksgiving is the one holiday that’s basically all tradition, so it feels like home turf for us. Polly’s Pop started bottling soda in Independence, Missouri, in 1923, and we still run it through a 1940s bottling machine, a few cases at a time.
Every flavor is made with pure cane sugar and goes into glass bottles. It’s also caffeine-free and gluten-free, which matters more than you’d think when you’re handing a bottle to your grandmother at 9 p.m., or to a kid who absolutely does not need to be up until midnight.
There are 16 flavors in all, five of them diet. The simplest way to cover this whole post is a Mix & Match pack. Grab Ginger Beer, Root Beer, Cream, and Black Cherry, and every one of these non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks is covered.
Frequently Asked Questions
What can I serve at Thanksgiving instead of alcohol?
Anything cold and fizzy, really. Bubbles cut through rich food the same way wine does. Craft soda mixed with cranberry, cider, or pomegranate juice and a sprig of rosemary is about as easy as it gets, and sparkling water is a fine backup.
How many drinks do I need per guest for Thanksgiving?
Plan on two or three per person for a dinner that stretches over a few hours. If your crowd shows up early and stays for football, go with three. Leftover soda keeps. Running out at 5 p.m. is worse.
Can I make Thanksgiving mocktails ahead of time?
Partly. Mix the juice, cider, or tea the night before and keep it cold. Wait to add the soda until you’re pouring, or you’ll be serving flat drinks by dessert.
What soda goes best with turkey?
Ginger beer. Its bite stands up to gravy and buttery sides. Black cherry is a close second, especially if there’s a lot of cranberry sauce on the plate.
Before you hit the store
You don’t need a bar cart or a bartender for good non-alcoholic Thanksgiving drinks. A few bottles, some juice, a handful of herbs, and a bucket of ice will take care of the whole table, from the nine-year-old to the designated driver to the aunt who’s done with wine for good.
Stock up at the Polly’s Pop shop, or check the retail locator for a store near you in Kansas City. Just do it before Wednesday, when every grocery store in the metro turns into a contact sport.




